Since being hired in 2016, Kalani Sitake has emphasized the importance of sending players to the NFL, and in that regard, he has been very successful, for the most part. Ten BYU players have been selected in the past four NFL drafts. As of this writing, there are 22 former BYU football players in the NFL.
- Tyler Allgeier RB – Atlanta Falcons
- Zane Anderson S – Green Bay
- Chris Brooks RB – Miami Dolphins
- Brady Christensen OL – Carolina Panthers
- Michael Davis CB – Washington Commanders
- Blake Freeland, OL – Indianapolis Colts
- Jalen Hall QB – Minnesota Vikings
- Caleb Hayes CB – New York Giants
- Taysom Hill QB/TE – New Orleans Saints
- Dax Milne WR – Washington Commanders
- Puka Nacua WR – Los Angeles Rams
- Aidan Robbins RB – Cleveland Browns
- Kedon Slovis QB – Indianapolis Colts
- Kingsley Suamataia OL – Kansas City Chiefs
- Sione Takitaki LB – New England Patriots
- Kiris Tonga DL – Arizona Cardinals
- Max Tooley LB – Houston Texans
- Kyle Van Noy LB – Baltimore Ravens
- Fred Warner LB – San Francisco 49ers
- Chris Wilcox CB – Los Angeles Chargers
- Jamaal Williams RB – New Orleans Saints
- Zach Wilson QB – Denver Broncos
BYU has at least one player in the NFL at every position except defensive end, and while BYU doesn't have a true tight end in the NFL, Taysom Hill is listed as a tight end in a hybrid role. Quality is more impressive than quantity.
Fred Warner is considered one of the best linebackers in the league. Warner has been a key part of the San Francisco defense for the past few years. Kyle Van Noy continues to be a major player in the league as an edge rusher for the Baltimore Ravens.
Wide receiver Puka Nacua broke the rookie receiving record in his first season with the Los Angeles Rams.
Tyler Allgaier and Jamaal Williams rushed for 1,000 yards in 2022.
With Kedon Slovis now in the NFL, BYU will have three former quarterbacks on its roster in Zach Wilson, Jalen Hall and Kedon Slovis.